Nov
15

The move, Part 2: How I was nearly deported

By

As we were landing in Dublin I was trying to decide what to say to the customs agent. Yes, I’m registered with the foreign births entry – so I’m technically a citizen – I have a piece of paper telling me so, but that paper is currently in the hands of the Irish consulate – they’re processing my application for an Irish passport. It should be back in 5 weeks. I’m allowed in the country for 90 days with my American passport. My plan is to stay here and hunt for jobs while I wait for the passport to come in, then I’ll head over to the UK or Austria for a weekend, leaving as an American and reentering as an Irishman. But how do I explain this delicate situation? I could lie, tell him that I’m just vacationing and most likely get in scot-free, but if I’m caught in my lie I’ll be in serious trouble. So I decide to tell the truth.

I approach the immigration agent. “How long are you planning to stay in Ireland?” he asks.
“60 days.”
“60? Six-zero?”
“Yeah.”
“What’s the purpose of your visit?”
“Well, I’m planning to move here, so for now I’m just doing a little job hunting, some exploring, trying to figure out some job possibilities.”
“Move here? You can’t just do that.”
“Oh, right. Well, I’m a dual citizen. I’m in the process of getting my Irish passport. I’m here to do some networking, then I’ll leave the country and return when I have my Irish passport.”
“Do you have any proof of being an Irish citizen?”
“Well, the papers are with the Irish consulate – they’re processing my application.”
“Hm. Well, how much money do you have on you?”
“Right now? 90euro.”
He looks up from my passport and raises his eyebrows. “You have 90euro to stay here for sixty days?”
“Well, I have a lot more than that in my bank account, that’s just the petty cash I had exchanged at the airport.”
“Do you have any proof of that?”

Things went downhill from here. He never got off the fact that I had only 90euro to my name and couldn’t prove otherwise. Pulling up my bank statement on my computer did nothing for him because “How do I know you didn’t doctor that?” Do you have any skills? Did you have a job in the States? What do you do?” I tell him and he asks if I have a resume. I do, but it’s on my computer and again, he says he can’t be sure I didn’t just make it all up.

Then he starts his lecture. “You didn’t really think this through, did you? You know, if I were to come to America and give the answers you’re giving me, I’d be in an interrogation room for hours and likely sent home. You sound pretty naive to me. Do you know how few jobs there are in Ireland right now? I’ll have to talk to my manager about this, because you have to understand I can’t just let you in with the information you’re giving me.”

When I was researching coming here I found that I was entitled to stay 90 days in the country with my American passport without any special visa. That’s how it worked when I studied here, that’s what the consulate told me. I never thought I’d have to prove that I would be a productive member of society, that I’d have to show a bank note. Of course, it all seemed obvious in hindsight. As I sat in the waiting area, I heard him make call after call, talking to managers. I could only make out bits and pieces of what he was saying, “He just comes here with no money and expects us to…if he wasn’t bloody American it wouldn’t be such an issue…it’s a fucking Saturday morning how am I supposed to confirm any of what he’s telling me?” I started dying a little inside. Everything I’ve worked for was going to be put to a stop before I even got in the country. Finally, he approaches me with his boss. The boss asks me the same set of questions, and I answer, this time a little more labored. My mouth feels like cotton. My heart is racing. I’m panicking. I’m not giving good answers. With each word I say I sound more and more like a vagrant.

“How much money do you have in your bank account,” bossman asks.
“Uh, over $2000,” I reply. I was wrong – I actually have 2000euros, not dollars.
“So you have 1400euros, roughly? For 60 days? That’s only about 100euro a week. You can’t live on that.”
“Well, uh, I plan to, ahem, live frugally.”
“Do you have a return flight?”
“Well, no. I’m going to see how things are going and then get the plane ticket when it’s time.”
“And how do you expect to pay for that plane ticket?”

I can see how poorly I’m doing. I can see everything crumbling. But when you’re panicked and pushed into a corner like that, it’s hard to recover. He asks if my parents know that I’m doing this, I answer that yes, they’re supportive of me. So they’ll support you if you get into trouble, he asks. Yes. What’s their phone number? I give it to him, and he goes to call my parents. Nothing like getting a 2am call from a customs agent, eh mom?

According to my mom, he told her a lot of the same things he told me: He can’t just up and move. Do you realize how bad the Irish job market is? He seems pretty unprepared, etc.

My mom replies, “Yes, we know how bad things are there, they’re not so good over here, either. We know he’s doing this; he’s been planning it for well over a year now. If he runs out of money then he’ll come home. He’s young, he wants to have an adventure.”

He lets me wait it out for a good 20 minutes before calling me over. He puts a stamp on my passport and starts writing on the stamp.

“I’m giving you 30 days, because you don’t have the money to survive for much longer than that, right? If you’re getting along okay, you’ve got a job, here’s what you’ll do. Go to the Garda in Galway, ask to speak to the immigration agent, and he can extend your time here. Otherwise, you’ve got to go home.”

I thank him and apologize for not having papers, and he launches into The Lecture again. At the end I thank him again and he says, “Do me a favor, okay? Go call your mum. She’s worried sick on account of me.”

“I will, thank you.” I leave to call her to tell her I’m okay, hop on a bus to Galway, and have a very difficult 3-hour bus ride. This guy really shook me up. As I write this, over 24 hours after the encounter, I’m still pretty out of sorts. He thought so little of me. It’s hard to shake his lack of confidence in me. Why is it strangers can have such an effect on my self-confidence?

So now I have until December 14 to get a job or get my Irish passport. This certainly raises the stakes. Here we go.
Thanks for the hospitality, Dublin.
(Part 3 coming tomorrow)

Categories : Blog Posts
  • Hanna

    Poor John! That guy sounds like a real asshole. Don’t let him freak you out! You’re great, and I’m sure you’ll find a job.

    I’m really enjoying your blog!! Keep at it!

  • Hanna

    Poor John! That guy sounds like a real asshole. Don’t let him freak you out! You’re great, and I’m sure you’ll find a job.

    I’m really enjoying your blog!! Keep at it!

  • Mary O’Sullivan

    John, great description of your experience with the Irish Immigration guy. I could feel your cottony mouth! I can see how that experience could shake you up. But try to use the experience to power you with even greater resolve to make this Ireland thing work out. You’re bright, personable, know how to network, have experience in supporting yourself, and are highly motivated to make this work. (Look at all the obstacles you’ve crossed already to get where you are). The immigration agent thought you were naive and unprepared. Perhaps. But you’re also adventurous, optimistic, and determined. If and when you get discouraged in your job-hunting, just think of that guy and the satisfaction you will feel when you prove him wrong! And if you are not able to find employment, think of the great adventure and learning experience you’ve had in 2009! My advice for the day: Go to the Queensworth, buy some groceries, and avoid the temptation to eat out. You’ll save tons of $$. Love you! MA

  • Mary O’Sullivan

    John, great description of your experience with the Irish Immigration guy. I could feel your cottony mouth! I can see how that experience could shake you up. But try to use the experience to power you with even greater resolve to make this Ireland thing work out. You’re bright, personable, know how to network, have experience in supporting yourself, and are highly motivated to make this work. (Look at all the obstacles you’ve crossed already to get where you are). The immigration agent thought you were naive and unprepared. Perhaps. But you’re also adventurous, optimistic, and determined. If and when you get discouraged in your job-hunting, just think of that guy and the satisfaction you will feel when you prove him wrong! And if you are not able to find employment, think of the great adventure and learning experience you’ve had in 2009! My advice for the day: Go to the Queensworth, buy some groceries, and avoid the temptation to eat out. You’ll save tons of $$. Love you! MA

  • Amanda Revere

    Hey, John. Almost the same thing happened to me when I moved there about 12 years ago. I’m not a citizen, and the customs agent must have just figured out that I was planning on staying in the country and working illegally. I didn’t have a return flight booked. He said I didn’t have enough money to keep myself alive for the three months I told him I was planning to stay. It took about an hour for me to get through with a tourist visa. And that was that. I was there for 10 months, leaving Ireland a few time to visit friends in Denmark and Germany. I rented a flat in Cork and got a job in a cafe. It was fine. I think there are a lot of British and Australian kids who go there with no job and end up squatting and panhandling, so they try to discourage young people from coming to stay indefinitely. But they can’t really enforce it. You’ll be fine. Have fun!

  • Amanda Revere

    Hey, John. Almost the same thing happened to me when I moved there about 12 years ago. I’m not a citizen, and the customs agent must have just figured out that I was planning on staying in the country and working illegally. I didn’t have a return flight booked. He said I didn’t have enough money to keep myself alive for the three months I told him I was planning to stay. It took about an hour for me to get through with a tourist visa. And that was that. I was there for 10 months, leaving Ireland a few time to visit friends in Denmark and Germany. I rented a flat in Cork and got a job in a cafe. It was fine. I think there are a lot of British and Australian kids who go there with no job and end up squatting and panhandling, so they try to discourage young people from coming to stay indefinitely. But they can’t really enforce it. You’ll be fine. Have fun!

  • Patricia Quigg

    Hey John, Your thoughtful Mom emailed me your blog page so here I am and am just astonished at the agent you encountered. I totally admire your honesty because ANYBODY would feel intimidated by such an experience!!! And how devastating if you had to return after all your planning!!! I will keep you in my prayers that a good job comes your way!! Just take it a day at a time and trust it will work out the way it should. Lovingly, Patricia

  • Patricia Quigg

    Hey John, Your thoughtful Mom emailed me your blog page so here I am and am just astonished at the agent you encountered. I totally admire your honesty because ANYBODY would feel intimidated by such an experience!!! And how devastating if you had to return after all your planning!!! I will keep you in my prayers that a good job comes your way!! Just take it a day at a time and trust it will work out the way it should. Lovingly, Patricia

  • Cheri

    whoops … sorry , I missed that part about your passport is in process… which consulate ??? do you have a copy of your foreign birth registration to take to the garda in Galway???

    I saw another comment about looking at jobs in Dublin … also check out Cork .. it’s a university city … lots to do and recently voted one of the best cities in the world.

    There isn’t alot going on here in Kerry ……….

  • Cheri

    whoops … sorry , I missed that part about your passport is in process… which consulate ??? do you have a copy of your foreign birth registration to take to the garda in Galway???

    I saw another comment about looking at jobs in Dublin … also check out Cork .. it’s a university city … lots to do and recently voted one of the best cities in the world.

    There isn’t alot going on here in Kerry ……….

  • Johnny G

    John,

    Saw your posts on MTI and checked out you blog. Best thing to do is forget what happened with customs guy – I have Irish relatives that get hassled by customs when visiting USA. Things are tough in Ireland right now but I’m really hoping things work out for you in Galway!

    Good luck!

    -John G

  • Johnny G

    John,

    Saw your posts on MTI and checked out you blog. Best thing to do is forget what happened with customs guy – I have Irish relatives that get hassled by customs when visiting USA. Things are tough in Ireland right now but I’m really hoping things work out for you in Galway!

    Good luck!

    -John G

  • http://seth-meyer.com Seth

    Wow. Dishing out the truth. Courageous! (I would have lied my head off.) You’re such a good boy, John! Glad you made it through!

  • http://seth-meyer.com Seth

    Wow. Dishing out the truth. Courageous! (I would have lied my head off.) You’re such a good boy, John! Glad you made it through!

  • Brandon

    Geez. That was compelling. Like tachycardic, where the hell is my popcorn compelling. Sorry to hear about all that, but at this rate this blog’s going to be fantastic! Best of luck with the job/passport situation!

  • Brandon

    Geez. That was compelling. Like tachycardic, where the hell is my popcorn compelling. Sorry to hear about all that, but at this rate this blog’s going to be fantastic! Best of luck with the job/passport situation!

  • Ann

    HIGH-larious. Next time tell the custom agent you were coming to Ireland to peel potatoes.

  • Ann

    HIGH-larious. Next time tell the custom agent you were coming to Ireland to peel potatoes.

  • Esther

    Man. So true. Sometimes honesty isn’t the best policy. :-)

    Cheri is right. I hope you have a scanned or hard copy of your citizenship cert somewhere.

    Glad that’s over with. Now let me move on to your next update…

  • Esther

    Man. So true. Sometimes honesty isn’t the best policy. :-)

    Cheri is right. I hope you have a scanned or hard copy of your citizenship cert somewhere.

    Glad that’s over with. Now let me move on to your next update…

  • Mary O’Sullivan

    How fortunate you are to have your contact Cheri who has all the practical advice to offer. Keep in touch with that woman!

  • Mary O’Sullivan

    How fortunate you are to have your contact Cheri who has all the practical advice to offer. Keep in touch with that woman!

  • Mendesmeirelles

    I'm am in the very same situation you was when you decided to move to Ireland.I've recently received my dual nationality as well(brazilian/Portuguese)and Im planning to go to Ireland next year.Im 23 yr and graduating this yearCongratulations for your blog,gabriel

  • Mendesmeirelles

    I'm am in the very same situation you was when you decided to move to Ireland.I've recently received my dual nationality as well(brazilian/Portuguese)and Im planning to go to Ireland next year.Im 23 yr and graduating this year
    Congratulations for your blog,
    gabriel

  • Mendesmeirelles

    I'm am in the very same situation you was when you decided to move to Ireland.I've recently received my dual nationality as well(brazilian/Portuguese)and Im planning to go to Ireland next year.Im 23 yr and graduating this yearCongratulations for your blog,gabriel

  • Mendesmeirelles

    I'm am in the very same situation you was when you decided to move to Ireland.I've recently received my dual nationality as well(brazilian/Portuguese)and Im planning to go to Ireland next year.Im 23 yr and graduating this year
    Congratulations for your blog,
    gabriel